# Operational semantics of REBOL/Red/Revolt?

**URL:** <https://revolt.metaeducation.com/forum/t/operational-semantics-of-rebol-red-ren-c/1456>\
**Category:** Development\
**Created:** [January 4, 2021, 4:00pm UTC](https://revolt.metaeducation.com/forum/t/operational-semantics-of-rebol-red-ren-c/1456 "2021-01-04T16:00:29Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Showing post:** 4

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![hostilefork](https://revolt.metaeducation.com/forum/user_avatar/revolt.metaeducation.com/hostilefork/32/421_2.png) [@hostilefork](https://revolt.metaeducation.com/forum/u/hostilefork)\
**Post date:** [January 4, 2021, 9:09pm UTC](https://revolt.metaeducation.com/forum/t/operational-semantics-of-rebol-red-ren-c/1456/4 "2021-01-04T21:09:45Z")

</div>

> [@okram](#):
>
> I understand that it would look different than the lambda calculus and in my opinion it would not have to be formal to be useful (at least not initially).

I'm definitely in favor of seeing something to this effect happen! I have my hands full with what I'm doing, but would can help how I can; there's a lot written here and I can kind of "index" it to answer most questions (often the answer is "here's the point where that issue reached a blocking point".)

To me, binding is the gaping hole in Rebol semantics. It's left out of the user guides...which consist of a lot of "what" with almost no "why". You learn how to mutate an unusual data structure, and are given some turnkey functions for internet and graphics that worked well cross-platform. It was a good zero-installation power tool for its time. Especially useful is PARSE--I don't know if you've messed with it much but it's quite a good example of a dialect in action.

Regarding binding: One of the problems that motivated me to start hacking on what became Revolt was the issue of "definitional returns". [I describe it in this post.](https://revolt.metaeducation.com/forum/t/the-canonical-list-of-non-negotiables/1244) It might be another illuminating example, for understanding the difference between Rebol2/Red and Revolt.

More binding info:

- [specific binding](https://revolt.metaeducation.com/forum/t/relative-binding-and-frame-internals/1344)
- [derived binding](https://github.com/metaeducation/ren-c/pull/727)
- and now, [virtual binding](https://github.com/metaeducation/ren-c/blob/master/tests/context/virtual-bind.test.reb)... (!)

I'd be happy to see it all replaced by better ideas, but these are the best I have so far for making the user experience that Rebol tried to give have a more legitimate basis.

---

_[View the full topic](https://revolt.metaeducation.com/forum/t/operational-semantics-of-rebol-red-ren-c/1456)._
